Possibly. Under US law, a token is a security if it is itself a financial instrument or is sold as part of an investment contract under the Howey test. The SEC's March 2026 interpretation says most tokens are not themselves securities, but token sales backed by team promises usually are investment contracts until those promises are fulfilled or abandoned.
Key takeaways
- Separate the token from the transaction. Under the SEC's March 17, 2026 interpretation, a token can be a non-security while the sale of it is an investment contract.
- Your own words create the investment contract. Whitepapers, official channels and detailed roadmaps are what regulators read.
- Investment contracts can end when you deliver, or publicly abandon, the promised work. Unregistered sales made before then remain violations.
- The SEC is not the only risk. Courts, states and private plaintiffs are not bound by SEC interpretations. The CLARITY Act is stalled and Regulation Crypto Assets is only a proposal.
- Pre-launch sales to US persons are still securities offerings. Run them through Reg D, Reg S or Reg CF, or do not run them.
- Outside the US, the test is different. MiCA, the UK and the UAE classify tokens on their own terms.
How the Howey test applies to crypto tokens
The Securities Act lists "investment contract" among the instruments that count as a security. The Supreme Court defined it in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co. (1946). Courts and the SEC summarize the test as “an investment of money in a common enterprise with an expectation of profits derived from the efforts of others.” Every US token analysis still starts there, and the SEC's 2026 interpretation expressly does not replace it.
Investment of money
"Money" is not limited to cash; paying ETH or USDC at a token sale clearly qualifies. The hard cases are airdrops, points programs and tokens earned for work. The SEC now addresses airdrops directly (below), but not token compensation for employees and contractors.
Common enterprise
Courts treat this as a required element, and the March 2026 interpretation now agrees, disavowing older Commission statements suggesting otherwise. Pooling sale proceeds in a treasury that funds development is the classic fact pattern. Circuits still differ on whether "vertical" commonality is enough, so the forum can matter.
Expectation of profits
Most token cases are decided here. The question is whether a reasonable buyer expects the token to gain value because of the team's work, not whether it has some use. The SEC looks at what the issuer promised, through which channels and when. Post-sale statements do not convert a sale into an investment contract, and unaffiliated promoters' statements are not attributed to the issuer unless it authorized them or colluded.
From the essential managerial efforts of others
The efforts must be the significant ones that determine success or failure, not ministerial tasks. The SEC's own example of promises likely to create an expectation of profit is a business plan with milestones, timeline, personnel, funding and an explanation of how holders benefit. Vague aspirations likely do not. The uncomfortable implication: the more polished your roadmap, the more it reads like an investment contract.
What actually moves the needle
- Pre-launch sales. Selling tokens, or rights to future tokens, before the network works is the strongest fact against you. The interpretation treats a SAFT as a sale at signing, whenever tokens are delivered.
- Marketing. Price talk, return figures, buybacks or burns pitched as value support, and listing promises all point to profit from your efforts.
- Team and foundation control. Large insider allocations, a treasury funding all development and admin keys over upgrades make holders dependent on you.
- Economic rights. Revenue share, fee distributions or issuer-paid yield push a token toward the "digital security" category.
- Decentralization. It matters more narrowly now. If you promised to "decentralize," the SEC will measure you against your own definition.
The token vs. the investment contract: Ripple and what came after
The central idea in current US token law is that the asset and the transaction are different things. The citrus groves in Howey were not securities; the package of land sales and service contracts was.
Judge Analisa Torres applied that logic in SEC v. Ripple Labs on July 13, 2023. XRP was not, in and of itself, an investment contract. Ripple's direct sales to institutional buyers were investment contracts. Its programmatic sales on exchanges, where buyers could not know they were buying from Ripple, were not. Other judges in the same court declined to follow that distinction, including in the Terraform and Coinbase cases. We covered the ruling when it came out: Decoding Ripple's ruling.
The case ended without an appellate decision. Final judgment in August 2024 imposed a civil penalty of about $125 million and a permanent injunction. Under new SEC leadership, the parties asked Judge Torres to cut the penalty and lift the injunction; she refused in 2025, and both sides dropped their appeals in August 2025. The 2023 ruling remains a district court decision: persuasive, not binding.
The SEC's March 2026 interpretation adopts Ripple's core insight with a different secondary-market test. A token sold under an investment contract carries that contract into secondary trading only if buyers would reasonably expect the issuer's promises to remain connected to the token. Whether the buyer knew the seller is beside the point. That helps a token whose roadmap is finished and hurts one still trading on an unfinished roadmap, even on an exchange.
SEC crypto token guidance in 2026: where things stand
Crypto Task Force and Project Crypto
The SEC launched its Crypto Task Force on January 21, 2025, led by Commissioner Hester Peirce. Chairman Paul Atkins announced Project Crypto on July 31, 2025, directing the agency to modernize its rules for on-chain markets. Peirce resigned effective October 2, 2026, and the SEC's Crypto Task Force page names no successor lead.
Dismissed enforcement cases
During 2025 the SEC dropped most of its registration-only crypto cases, including those against Coinbase, Kraken, Consensys and Binance. A dismissal reflects enforcement priorities. It is not a ruling that the tokens involved were not securities.
The 2025 staff statements
The Division of Corporation Finance issued statements on meme coins (February 27, 2025), proof-of-work mining (March 20, 2025), stablecoins (April 4, 2025), protocol staking (May 29, 2025) and liquid staking (August 5, 2025). Staff statements have no legal force, and the March 2026 interpretation supersedes them on those topics.
The March 2026 token taxonomy
On March 17, 2026, the SEC, joined by the CFTC, issued Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto Assets and Certain Transactions Involving Crypto Assets (Release No. 33-11412), effective March 23, 2026. It is a Commission-level interpretation. It supersedes the staff's 2019 "Framework for 'Investment Contract' Analysis of Digital Assets," and the SEC says it will apply it in enforcement. The CFTC said it will administer the Commodity Exchange Act consistently.
| Category | What it covers | Status of the asset itself |
|---|---|---|
| Digital commodity | Value tied to the programmatic operation of a functional network plus supply and demand, with no passive yield or claim on a business. The release named 16 examples, including BTC, ETH, SOL and XRP. | Not a security |
| Digital collectible | Items designed to be collected or used, such as art, in-game items and meme coins | Not a security (fractionalization can change this) |
| Digital tool | Tokens with a practical function: memberships, tickets, credentials, identity | Not a security |
| Stablecoin | Payment stablecoins of permitted GENIUS Act issuers; until the Act takes effect, "Covered Stablecoins" | Not a security; other stablecoins depend on the facts |
| Digital security | Stock, notes and other traditional securities in token form | Always a security |
The first four categories describe the asset, not the deal; any of them can be sold subject to an investment contract. That contract ends when the issuer fulfills its promised essential managerial efforts, or when buyers can no longer reasonably expect it to, such as after a widely disseminated announcement abandoning development. But an unregistered, non-exempt sale made while the contract existed remains a violation, and fraud liability survives.
Utility token vs. security token
The "utility token" label has never decided anything. Its closest analogue is the digital tool, a narrow category: a token with a practical function whose value the creator does not promise to drive. A utility token sold before the utility exists, on the strength of the roadmap, is a non-security asset sold under an investment contract. That is the most common fact pattern we see.
Airdrops and securities law
Under the interpretation, an airdrop of a non-security token involves no "investment of money" when recipients give the issuer “no money, goods, services, or other consideration” in exchange. Retroactive drops based on past activity qualify, if recipients need do nothing further after the airdrop is announced. If they must buy a token, buy a product or complete tasks after the announcement, the guidance does not apply. That puts many points and quest campaigns outside the safe zone. Airdrops of digital securities are not covered.
Regulation Crypto Assets: proposed, not final
On August 18, 2026, the SEC proposed Regulation Crypto Assets (Release No. 33-11434). It would create:
- A one-time startup exemption: up to $5 million over up to four years, with public filings at the start and end and principles-based disclosure.
- A fundraising exemption modeled partly on Regulation A: Tier 1 up to $20 million and Tier 2 up to $75 million per 12 months, with financial statements, ongoing reporting and investment limits for non-accredited investors.
- An investment contract safe harbor: once the issuer has completed or permanently ceased all promised essential managerial efforts, makes no new promises and files a certification with supporting analysis, the token is deemed no longer subject to the investment contract.
- A "qualified purchaser" definition preempting state registration for offerings under the exemptions and certain secondary trades.
Comments closed October 20, 2026. None of this is law until the Commission adopts a final rule, which may differ. Separately, the SEC's September 2026 "innovation exemption" order addresses trading of tokenized equities, not token launches.
Stablecoins and the GENIUS Act
The GENIUS Act (S. 1582, Public Law 119-27), signed July 18, 2025, removes a "payment stablecoin issued by a permitted payment stablecoin issuer" from the definition of security. Permitted issuers may not pay holders interest or yield solely for holding the coin. The Act takes effect on the earlier of 18 months after enactment or 120 days after final regulations; the OCC finalized its rule on October 21, 2026 and states the Act takes effect January 18, 2027. Until then, the SEC treats "Covered Stablecoins" as non-securities.
The lesson is narrow. GENIUS protects reserved, redeemable payment coins from approved issuers. Yield-bearing "stablecoins," synthetic dollars and coins from unpermitted issuers get the ordinary facts-and-circumstances analysis, and yield is what most often makes them securities.
The CLARITY Act: stalled in the Senate
The CLARITY Act (H.R. 3633) would split jurisdiction by statute, giving the CFTC digital commodities and their spot markets and the SEC digital securities. The House passed it 294–134 on July 17, 2025. The Senate Banking Committee advanced its version in May 2026 with every Republican and two Democrats in favor. On September 15, 2026, cloture on the motion to proceed failed 49–50. Senator Tillis switched his vote to preserve a motion to reconsider, so the bill is technically alive. Disputes over ethics rules, stablecoin yield, illicit finance and state preemption remain unresolved.
We are not aware of further floor action as of mid-November 2026. If the bill is not enacted before the 119th Congress ends in January 2027, it must be reintroduced. Plan under current law and the SEC's interpretation, not CLARITY's definitions.
State law and private lawsuits: risks the SEC can't waive
An SEC interpretation governs how the SEC enforces. It does not bind federal judges, state regulators or private plaintiffs, and a future Commission can revise it. Three exposures remain:
- State regulators. States enforce their own securities laws, and some use tests broader than Howey, such as California's risk-capital test. Oregon's attorney general sued Coinbase in April 2025 over 31 tokens under Oregon's broader test. Eighteen state attorneys general opposed CLARITY's preemption provisions. Reg CA's preemption would cover only offerings under it, and only if adopted.
- Private Section 12(a)(1) claims. Buyers in an unregistered, non-exempt offering can sue for rescission without proving fraud. The interpretation confirms investors keep those rights even after the token separates from the investment contract. Claims generally must be brought within one year of the violation and three years of the offering.
- Fraud claims. Rule 10b-5 and state consumer-protection claims do not depend on registration status, and issuers who abandon a project remain liable for misstatements made while selling it.
Class actions over unregistered tokens slowed sharply in 2025 and 2026, but the claims remain available, and the SEC's limitation period for civil penalties is five years.
Outside the US: MiCA, UK and UAE token classification
| Jurisdiction | How tokens are classified | What it means for a launch |
|---|---|---|
| EU (MiCA) | MiFID II financial instruments fall outside MiCA and under securities rules. Otherwise: e-money tokens (one official currency), asset-referenced tokens (other values or baskets) and "other crypto-assets." | White paper for public offers or trading admission of other crypto-assets, subject to exemptions; authorization for EMT and ART issuers. CASP transitional periods ended July 1, 2026. |
| UK | Security tokens are specified investments under FSMA. Most other cryptoassets are covered today by financial promotion rules and AML registration. | A new FCA regime, including admissions and disclosures rules, is expected to apply from October 25, 2027. |
| UAE | The regulator depends on location: VARA in Dubai, FSRA in ADGM, DFSA in DIFC, the Capital Market Authority (formerly SCA) onshore, the CBUAE for payment tokens. ADGM distinguishes virtual assets from digital securities. | VARA requires a license to issue fiat- and asset-referenced tokens; other issuances generally run through licensed distributors with binding whitepapers. |
MiCA has no Howey. The EU question is whether a token's rights make it a financial instrument, guided by ESMA's guidelines on that qualification. A token sold under a US investment contract can be an ordinary "other crypto-asset" in the EU, while one carrying profit rights can be a MiFID instrument. Where you incorporate, license and sell is part of the classification work, which is why our regulatory strategy engagements cover token classification and jurisdiction selection together.
Is my token a security? A self-assessment
Founders can run these questions against their plans; investors, against a project's public materials. One high-risk answer does not make a token a security, and all low-risk answers are not a clearance.
| Question | Lower risk | Higher risk |
|---|---|---|
| Did anyone pay for tokens or token rights before launch? | No, or only under Reg D or Reg S | Yes, including US retail |
| Does the token carry revenue, profit or issuer-paid yield? | No | Yes |
| Does the network work today? | Live and usable | Whitepaper or testnet only |
| What did official channels promise? | Features and documentation | Price, returns, listings, buybacks |
| Who does the essential work now? | Independent contributors; roadmap complete | Core team funded by the token treasury |
| How are insider tokens handled? | Disclosed, long lockups | Large, early or undisclosed unlocks |
| What must airdrop recipients do? | Nothing after announcement | Tasks or purchases after announcement |
| Have you announced completion of promised work? | Yes, in detail | No; the roadmap is open-ended |
Token launch legal design: choices that reduce risk
- Do not sell tokens to US retail before launch. This single choice removes most of the exposure.
- Treat SAFTs and token warrants as securities offerings. Use Rule 506(b) or 506(c) of Reg D for accredited investors, Reg S for offshore buyers with flowback controls, or Reg CF (up to $5 million per 12 months through a registered portal). Regulation Crypto Assets may add paths if adopted.
- Lock up team and investor tokens. Tie unlocks to vesting and milestones, disclose the schedule and respect resale restrictions on Reg D securities.
- Write promises you can finish. Define the essential work, its milestones and what "done" means, then announce completion publicly. The interpretation encourages this; the proposed safe harbor would formalize it.
- Disclose properly. Token economics, insider allocations, treasury, governance and risks. Disclosure won't make a token a non-security, but it is your best defense to fraud claims.
- Keep profit talk out of official channels. No price predictions, return figures or buyback promises. Coordinated promoters' statements can be attributed to you, so control influencer arrangements.
- Design airdrops to fit the guidance. Use retroactive allocations with no post-announcement tasks or purchases.
- Geo-fence where it matters. Block US persons from sales and certain incentives with IP blocking, KYC and attestations, and document it.
- Publish a decentralization roadmap you define. The SEC measures you against your own definition, so be precise about what you will hand off and when.
When to get a token legal opinion, and what it won't do
A token legal memo applies the law to your facts: sales history, token rights, marketing, governance and roadmap. Get one before any sale (including SAFTs), token generation, airdrop or listing application; when you add a fee switch, staking program or buyback; and before announcing that promised work is complete.
A memo forces disciplined fact-gathering, gives exchanges, market makers, auditors and investors something to diligence, and documents good faith, which can matter for fraud claims and penalties.
It does not bind the SEC, any court or any state regulator. It is no defense to a Section 12(a)(1) claim, which is strict liability. It goes stale when your facts change, and it cannot cure marketing that contradicts it. Most are reasoned analyses with stated assumptions, not clean "this is not a security" opinions. Be skeptical of anyone who promises otherwise.
Joseph Collement has advised crypto companies on these questions since 2017, including advising Binance in 2019 on securities-law compliance for the launch of BNB. For teams that need the analysis kept current as the product and the rules change, we offer ongoing general counsel services.
Sources & further reading
- SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293 (1946)
- SEC: Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto Assets and Certain Transactions Involving Crypto Assets (File No. S7-2026-09)
- SEC/CFTC interpretive release, Release Nos. 33-11412; 34-105020 (PDF)
- SEC press release 2026-30: SEC Clarifies Application of Federal Securities Laws to Crypto Assets
- SEC press release 2026-76: SEC Proposes New Regulation Crypto Assets
- SEC fact sheet: Regulation Crypto Assets
- SEC proposing release: Regulation Crypto Assets, Release No. 33-11434 (PDF)
- Chairman Paul S. Atkins, remarks launching Project Crypto (July 31, 2025)
- SEC Crypto Task Force
- SEC: Commissioner Hester M. Peirce (former)
- SEC Division of Corporation Finance: Staff Statement on Meme Coins (Feb. 27, 2025)
- SEC Division of Corporation Finance: Staff Statement on Certain Proof-of-Work Mining Activities (Mar. 20, 2025)
- SEC Division of Corporation Finance: Statement on Stablecoins (Apr. 4, 2025)
- SEC Division of Corporation Finance: Statement on Certain Protocol Staking Activities (May 29, 2025)
- SEC Division of Corporation Finance: Statement on Certain Liquid Staking Activities (Aug. 5, 2025)
- SEC v. Ripple Labs, Inc., Opinion and Order (S.D.N.Y. July 13, 2023)
- Cointelegraph: SEC and Ripple drop appeals (Aug. 2025)
- GENIUS Act, S. 1582 (Public Law 119-27)
- OCC News Release 2026-92: Final Rule to Implement GENIUS Act (Oct. 21, 2026)
- CLARITY Act, H.R. 3633
- Orrick: The CLARITY Act Stalls in the Senate (Oct. 2026)
- DLA Piper: Senate fails to advance the CLARITY Act (Sept. 2026)
- A&O Shearman: SEC unveils landmark interpretive guidance (2026)
- Orrick: SEC Issues Interpretive Guidance on Crypto Asset Classification (Apr. 2026)
- NERA: Recent Trends in Securities Class Action Litigation, H1 2026 Update
- Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA)
- ESMA statement on the end of transitional periods under MiCA (Apr. 2026)
- FCA: A new regime for cryptoasset regulation
- Clyde & Co: UAE virtual assets update, Q2 2026
- Regulation Tomorrow: UAE SCA renamed CMA (Jan. 2026)